Places and evidence contexts

Ocean iron fertilisation: Ocean evidence in geographic context.

Seven detailed records connect physical setting, plankton ecology, experiments, natural analogues, carbon fate, measurement, operations and governance.

A spatial anchor

Three ocean regions where iron limitation is a central research question.

Basin-scale setting provides the geographic frame for the evidence contexts. These bands show scientific context, not project areas or maritime boundaries.

Broad scientific context only: not HNLC boundaries, maritime boundaries, project sites or permission areas.
Coastline and shaded-relief base: Natural Earth ↗. HNLC context: Lin & Letscher (2024) ↗. The three curves are schematic; boundaries and seasonal expression vary.

Evidence classes

Each context contributes a different part of the answer.

How the seven contexts contribute
Evidence classContextsScientific contributionBoundary
Mesoscale field experimentIronEx, SEEDS, SAGEResponse, transport, community composition and particle observations under a stated intervention.One experiment is not a regional average, removal result or permission pathway.
Long-running observatoryOcean Station Papa / SERIESSeasonal context, physical variability and repeated observation around an enrichment study.Observatory evidence is not a permanent treatment-reference system.
Natural iron analogueGalápagos, Kerguelen, Crozet, South GeorgiaRecurring contrasts between iron supply, plankton communities and carbon pathways.Natural systems differ from a deliberate intervention and may be protected or disputed.
CounterevidenceSAGE, LOHAFEX and other records in the atlasShows why a physiological response or productivity increase need not become particle export.A low response in one setting is not a universal outcome.

Evidence base

Scientific basis for the seven contexts.

The evidence includes peer-reviewed experiments, long-term observations and natural-analogue studies.

Evidence first

Peer-reviewed experiments, long-term observations and natural-analogue studies.

Place matters

Physical setting, season, biology and governance are retained rather than averaged into a generic OIF story.

Limits remain visible

Biological response, carbon transfer to depth, atmospheric accounting and legal context remain distinct.

Sources & methods links primary and official records for treaty and governance status.